If you’re installing a new roof and trying to choose the best material for your home, you’re probably leaning towards shingles. Asphalt shingles are the most cost-effective and popular roofing material. However, roofers like this metal roofing Vancouver WA contractor swear by metal roofing due to its unmatched durability.
So, which is really better?
Below, we will compare the differences between traditional asphalt shingles and the new metal roofing trend based on:
- How they look
- Durability
- Overall performance
- Average cost
You’ll have a clearer idea of which roofing material is ideal for your home once you finish this metal roofing vs. shingles guide.
Style and Material Comparison
Asphalt was converted to its shingle form in the early 20th century, replacing wood, clay, and slate shingles as the norm. Over the years, they’ve remained relatively the same in their functionality.
The current three main shingle types are:
- 3-Tab shingles
- Dimensional shingles
- Luxury shingles
Today, asphalt shingles offer many colors to match your home’s exterior. All three types have differing styles, but especially dimensional and luxury shingles.
The developmental history of metal roofing is more of a complex journey. In the 18th century, metal roofs covered mansions but were popularized in the 19th century. At that point, mostly lead, tin, and copper were used.
The styles of metal materials for roofs have developed over time. Today, you can find metal roofing in the following materials:
- Copper
- Aluminum
- Galvalume Steel
- Galvanized Steel
- Tin
Many associate these materials with a rustic look, but the styles have modernized and can complement any household just as well as asphalt.
For style and material, both asphalt and metal offer variety. The true test is their overall longevity and durability.
What’s More Durable?
Hands-down, metal roofing’s resilience excels. Most of Mother Nature is no match for the metal materials, though some fare better than others. For example, steel is sturdier than copper. Your installer can go over any questions you may have.
Along with hardiness, the longevity of metal roofing is great too. The average lifespan is between 40 and 70 years and includes long-lasting warranties.
However, this material is not without weakness. Rainfall may sound a little louder with a metal roof. Heavy hail storms, falling branches, and walking improperly across the roof may dent it. But with a solid warranty, you should be covered.
Asphalt shingles have a lifespan ranging from 20 to 25 years, shorter than competing materials. Major cons include their susceptibility to damage, moisture retention, and reduced insulation. Their condition depends on the environment and its climate. Discuss concerns with your contractor or roofing inspector; they won’t hesitate to let you know what to expect.
Pricing Expectations
The reason asphalt roofing is so common is not for its hardiness — it’s for the low cost. According to Home Advisor, the standard range is between $5,200 and about $11,000 for total roof replacement. Not bad!
But, honestly, metal roofing doesn’t seem much higher. Home Advisor lists the average cost between $5,200 and $15,000.
Pricing will generally vary between regions, however. And it’s safe to say you’ll spend a little more on more durable materials.
Conclusion — Which Is Better?
Both metal roofing and asphalt shingles can look great on any home. But when it comes to strength and endurance, metal roofing wins. It’s less vulnerable to the elements and lasts over half a century. Metal roofing costs more than shingles, but when you consider longevity, it’s worth it.
